How TradeValues Prices a Trade and Picks the Winner
Updated
A fantasy trade calculator gives every player and pick a value, adds up each side and judges the gap between the totals. TradeValues uses the prices managers really pay in trades: within 5% of each other it's a fair trade, up to 15% one side has a slight edge, and past that one side wins. The values come from Stats Guy Fantasy and update every day (these are from November 20, 2026). Everything else is a fixed rule of ours, and each one is below with today's numbers, so you can check any verdict yourself.
Where do the TradeValues numbers come from?
From Stats Guy Fantasy, which works out what every player and pick is worth from completed trades in real fantasy leagues (11.9 million analyzed as of November 16, 2026, per its home page; how it builds the values). We use them under its API terms: one update a day, credited wherever values appear. The only change is the strategy setting, if you pick one: no expert tweaks, no crowd votes.
A player has two values, because the formats reward different things. A redraft team starts over each season, a dynasty team keeps its roster (Sleeper's league types page), so a dynasty value also counts the seasons after this one: Christian McCaffrey, 30, is worth 5,772 this season but 3,197 in dynasty (Superflex). And each value comes in a Superflex and a 1QB version, since a Superflex slot can start a second quarterback (Wikipedia).
| Calculator | Values | QB formats | TE premium levels | Picks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dynasty | Dynasty | Superflex, 1QB | None, TE premium, big premium | 2027, 2028, 2029: rounds 1 to 5, early, mid and late |
| Redraft | This season (redraft) | Superflex, 1QB | The same three | None: a pick scores nothing this season |
| Draft pick | Dynasty | Superflex, 1QB | Not used: TE premium doesn't change a pick | The same three drafts |
| Team value | Dynasty and this season | Superflex, 1QB | The same three | In dynasty, in the roster's total |
What do TE premium and big premium mean?
They're the source's two levels of tight end scoring bonus. Its API documentation defines TE premium as up to 1.0 extra point per catch, and big premium as more than 1.0 per catch or two or more starting tight end slots.
How often are the values updated?
Every day, shortly after Stats Guy Fantasy publishes its own update, and the date shows under every calculator and value table (today's values are from November 20, 2026). Each update is checked for gaps before it goes live; if anything looks wrong, the site keeps the last good values and tells you under the calculator once they're more than 3 days old.
What does a value of 10,000 mean?
It's the top of the scale: the most valuable player is about 10,000 and everyone else is measured against him. In Superflex dynasty today that's Jahmyr Gibbs at 10,000; Trey McBride, at 5,035, is worth about half as much in a trade.
How does TradeValues decide who wins a trade?
By the size of the gap compared with the bigger side, not by raw points: a 500-point gap is fair when the bigger side totals 10,000 (5.0%) and a clear win when it totals 1,500 (33.3%). We add up each side, take the difference and divide it by the bigger side; the share you see, to one decimal, is the one judged, so 5.0% is still fair and 5.1% is an edge.
| Verdict | Gap as a share of the bigger side | What the calculator shows |
|---|---|---|
| Fair trade | 0 to 5.0% | “Fair trade” |
| Slight edge | 5.1% to 15.0% | “Slight edge to you” or “to them”, plus what would balance it |
| One side wins | Over 15.0% | “You win this trade” (green) or “They win this trade” (red), plus what would balance it |
What would balance an unfair trade?
When the verdict isn't fair, the calculator suggests up to three players or picks, not already in the trade, each worth about the gap (within 25% of it), the closest first. One click adds the one you pick to the side that trails.
How are three-team trades judged?
By each team's net: what it gets minus what it gives. The team with the biggest net wins, and the trade is fair when no team comes out ahead by more than 5.0% of the biggest side. The verdict names the team (Team A, B or C), since a three-team trade has no single “you”.
How can you check a verdict yourself?
- Add up the values shown on each side.
- Subtract the smaller total from the bigger one.
- Divide the gap by the bigger total and compare it with the table above.
Nothing is hidden: every adjustment shows as a note under the verdict, and the settings that change values (strategy, TE premium, QB format) are yours.
What do the notes under the verdict mean?
Each note tells you something the two totals can't, and shows only when it applies:
| Note | When it appears | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidation | One side gets more players or picks than the other (a 2-for-1, say) | Who has to free up roster spots, and who gets the best player |
| Aging veteran | A dynasty player at or past the flag age (RB 27, WR 30, TE 30, QB 33) | His value tends to drop from here, so it's easiest to cash in now; with his 30-day change |
| Contending or Rebuilding | The strategy isn't Balanced | How your strategy moved the values |
| Superflex or 1QB | A quarterback is in the trade | What the biggest quarterback counts in the other format |
| TE premium | A tight end is in it and a premium is set | His value with and without the premium |
Why does TradeValues flag veterans at those ages?
The ages are our rule, not a published fact: managers pay less for each extra year of age, and we flag running backs earliest because buyers stop paying for them soonest. In today's top 40 dynasty assets the flag hits 3 running backs and nobody else. When to sell one is covered in what is dynasty fantasy football.
How do contending and rebuilding change a value?
Contending gives this season more weight: each value moves 30% of the way toward his value for this season alone. Rebuilding moves it 30% the other way, and Balanced leaves it alone. So a veteran who scores now gains for a contender, and a young player or a pick gains for a rebuilder. Only the dynasty and draft pick calculators have the setting.
The exact rule: value = dynasty value + w × (this season's value − dynasty value), with w = 0.3 for Contending, -0.3 for Rebuilding and 0 for Balanced, and never below 0.
A pick scores nothing this season, so it loses 30% for a contender and gains 30% for a rebuilder: the 2027 mid 1st counts 1,507, 2,153 and 2,799 for a contending, balanced and rebuilding team. Which setting fits your team is in should you contend or rebuild.
Why doesn't TradeValues discount package trades?
Because the values already do it. Stats Guy Fantasy's value curve page says its curve is steeper than other sites' on purpose, since “one elite producer beats two good ones you can't both start”; a discount on top would count that twice. Instead, the consolidation note shows the roster cost.
| Rank | Player | Value | Share of #1 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jahmyr Gibbs | 10,000 | 100% |
| 5 | Ja'Marr Chase | 8,022 | 80% |
| 10 | Amon-Ra St. Brown | 6,255 | 63% |
| 25 | Matthew Golden | 3,684 | 37% |
| 50 | Jared Goff | 2,186 | 22% |
| 100 | Michael Penix Jr. | 627 | 6% |
Values of . Data from Stats Guy Fantasy.
How to use this in a 2-for-1 or 3-for-1 offer is in how to trade in fantasy football.
How are rookie draft picks valued?
Each pick carries the source's value for its draft, round and third of the round (early, mid or late), for the next three drafts (2027, 2028, 2029). A pick's value is the same with or without TE premium, and picks aren't in the redraft calculator. On today's values a mid 2nd is worth about 27% of a mid 1st.
| Round | Mid pick value | Share of the mid 1st |
|---|---|---|
| 1st | 2,153 | 100% |
| 2nd | 576 | 27% |
| 3rd | 230 | 11% |
| 4th | 135 | 6% |
| 5th | 94 | 4% |
Values of . Data from Stats Guy Fantasy.
Every pick of the three drafts, with a player of about each pick's value, is in the draft pick trade calculator.
Is Jaxon Smith-Njigba for Brock Bowers and a 1st fair? A worked trade
You get Jaxon Smith-Njigba, today's 2nd dynasty asset, and give Brock Bowers (the 8th) and the 2027 mid 1st, in Superflex with the strategy on Balanced.
| Asset | Side | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Jaxon Smith-Njigba | You get | 9,609 |
| Brock Bowers | You give | 6,441 |
| 2027 mid 1st | You give | 2,153 |
| Total you get | 9,609 | |
| Total you give | 8,594 |
- The values: 9,609 for Jaxon Smith-Njigba, 6,441 for Brock Bowers and 2,153 for the pick.
- The totals: 9,609 you get against 8,594 you give.
- The gap: 1,015 points, 10.6% of the bigger side.
- The verdict: a slight edge to you, by the table above.
- The notes: Consolidation (one side gets two assets for one).
- What would balance it: Saquon Barkley (1,018), Ladd McConkey (1,006), Jadarian Price (1,045).
Open the trade calculator, add the same three and you'll see the same numbers.
What doesn't TradeValues price?
Anything the source doesn't publish a value for, and one thing on purpose:
- PPR, half-PPR or standard scoring
- League size
- Defensive players (IDP)
- Keeper costs
- Your roster or your standings
- News after the values date
- A package discount (on purpose, above)
Why is there no PPR setting?
Because the source publishes one value set per QB format and TE premium level, not one per scoring setting, and a guessed PPR multiplier would be an invented number. The values don't change with scoring, so in a close trade, weigh yours yourself: full PPR (a point per catch) favors players who catch a lot of passes, like pass-catching running backs.
How are rookies with no redraft value counted?
As 0 this season: they're not in the redraft calculator, and their season value is 0 in the contend and rebuild settings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did a trade's verdict change since yesterday?
Because the values update once a day. A player's market value moves with injuries, roles and trades, so the same trade can cross the 5.0% or 15.0% line from one day to the next; the date under the calculator says which day's values you see.
Why does the same trade get a different verdict in Superflex?
Because quarterbacks are worth far more there. Josh Allen is worth 9,196 in Superflex dynasty and 5,672 in 1QB, so any trade with a quarterback in it is priced differently in each format.
Can you change the fair-trade threshold?
No. 5.0% and 15.0% are fixed for every trade, so a shared link shows everyone the same verdict.
Does TradeValues use projections?
No. It uses market values, the prices managers pay in real trades, not points projections.
Is TradeValues affiliated with Stats Guy Fantasy?
No. TradeValues uses Stats Guy Fantasy's public API under its terms and credits it on every table of values.
Why do different trade calculators give different verdicts?
Each one uses its own values and its own rule for a fair trade. TradeValues' values and rules are the ones on this page, so you can check any verdict by hand.